Before It's Too Late

My grandson's teacher calls his mother to alert her that her son used the school internet inappropriately.

 Well of course he did. He has an undeveloped prefrontal cortex and he has a curious mind. Why does an eleven-year-old child have unlimited-internet access in school?

I also learn the teacher has a problem with students using youtube. "Why aren't those addictive websites blocked?" I ask my daughter. She doesn't know why they aren't.

 On April 10, the New York Times published an op-ed with the title Get Tech Out Of School Before It's Too Late by Jessica Grose. The article begins: 

Jaime Lewis noticed that her eighth-grade son’s grades were slipping several months ago. She suspected it was because he was watching YouTube during class on his school-issued laptop, and her suspicions were validated. “I heard this from two of his teachers and confirmed with my son: Yes, he watches YouTube during class, and no, he doesn’t think he can stop. In fact, he opted out of retaking a math test he’d failed, just so he could watch YouTube,” she said.

She decided to do something about it. Lewis told me that she got together with other parents who were concerned about the unfettered use of school-sanctioned technology in San Luis Coastal Unified School District, their district in San Luis Obispo, Calif. Because they knew that it wasn’t realistic to ask for the removal of the laptops entirely, they went for what they saw as an achievable win: blocking YouTube from students’ devices. A few weeks ago, they had a meeting with the district superintendent and several other administrators, including the tech director.

On the same front page was another tech invasion story. A high school had been inundated with sexually explicit images of a few of their female students, made through an AI software program. The focus of the article was a fourteen-year-old girl (whose images had been doctored), and her mother's fight to protect her child. At the time of printing, nothing had been done to counter the AI invasion. School policies or the problem itself had yet to be addressed five months after the first offense.

I try to think back on my fourteen-year-old self. I was in junior high and the experience would have been debilitating. Even though there is a clear understanding that the girls didn't participate in any way, it still would be a personal embarrassment.

Several months ago, I attended a college conference for the courses I teach in high school. The class addressed the recent influx of AI usage in the classroom--how to detect, what policies to implement, what AI help would be acceptable. A vocal and spirited teacher spoke up. She was thankful she was retiring because of the challenge this was bringing to English and writing teachers. At the moment, I wasn't considering retirement, but I quickly calculated the short-term effects of programs like chat GPt3.

We warned students; we showed them AI examples compared to real student writing; we warned about the effects of not thinking...we told them we could spot a fake instantly.

I started reading their responses with suspicion. When I read an obvious AI generated response, I wrote nice notes like I'd much rather see your work than a computer's. Some students apologized and some students didn't show up to class the next day. Then they avoided me. Some students learned how to mix their own thoughts with the computer's. And I always wondered, what if this really is their own writing? Am I making a false accusation?

I love reading students' thoughts. But I started to question everything. I realized that teaching writing would soon be obsolete. We were already living in the Truman show, and we had been taken over in a Stepford Wives invasion of thought.

I retired. The title of Jessica Grose's article has a special application: Get Tech Out of the Classroom--before the teachers quit.

The stinging irony in all of this is that Tony has been one of the pioneers in artificial intelligence.



Comments