Writing Muscle
At the end of our three-week summer institute for Central Utah Writing Project (CUWP), we received a prompt and asked to write for ten minutes. When time concluded, we shared our writing with colleagues at our table. We then decided on one response to share with the entire group. My writing was chosen. When I stood to read, I felt confident and liked what I’d written.
This read-aloud victory was the culmination of consecutive weeks of consistent writing, sometimes three hours a day.
I had built muscle—writing muscle.
And I wasn’t willing to lose the writing-muscle I’d worked so hard to gain.
I would have to keep writing.
But how would I keep writing and what would I write?
I was inspired by French writer and philosopher Michel de Montaigne, the father of the essay. In the sixteenth century he created the “essay” from the French word essayer: to try.
Previously, I had thought of an essay as a formal piece of writing with strict parameters, written by painful reflection and excessive revision. Writing an essay equaled putting on a straight jacket to meet a teacher’s expectations. Until Summer Writing Institute, I had never written an essay just “to try” or to have fun. I was determined to do just that, and determined to write an essay every day.
My essays would include subjects as simple as clouds, haircuts, or lying on marble benches at the Washington Monument. Titles represented complex ideas or events I was trying to understand: The Vietnam Conflict or The Provenance of a Painting. Through writing, I worked to deepen the meaning of and to explore life.
In my second year, I started a blog to track and archive my writing. I wrote for my own pleasure and for maintaining the writing muscle I had come to treasure. The blog would become a prized journal of thoughts, experiences, trials and triumphs, all written in essay form.
With my CUWP-inspired goal, and hundreds of written essays, it was time to share the secret of writing-muscle with my classes.
Essay-A-Day was born--a three-week endeavor starting the first week of students’ senior year. It has been part of my curriculum for seven years, and at year-end evaluations, it is often listed as one of the favorite activities in that course.
I aimed to give students the same freedom to explore that had been exhilarating for me, but students needed a place to start. While some of my essays may be a well-researched, most are personal narrative. My students start with personal narrative. Everyone's an expert on their own life. We begin creating with Nancie Atwell’s Territories (1)—all the areas in a person’s life that can be written about. We start with a brain-rush. I share my own list, projecting the document on the board and modeling for students as I record every recent or past detail that comes to mind:
- Hiking to Scout Falls
- The mean sister
- Family mental illness
- The expensive oxfords
- Strangled by technology
As they start their own lists, I keep typing publicly.
Volunteers then share three territories on the board and students vote on one they find the most interesting. I follow up with questions and often within minutes students know what they will write. Students recognize that starting an essay only takes a beginning kernel of an idea.
The student-chosen subject Cheetos and Oatmeal became an essay about angels and suffering. Jumping to Dad became an essay on the fear of leaving home after high school.
To guide and inspire students’ writing, I share several mentor-essays, some from former students. One essay was a gold key Scholastic winner, and the author is now writing her PhD at Harvard. The winning essay written her senior year, is linked to her current research. I remind students that we never know where our writing can take us. I emphasize that to write is to discover, and discovery is often my motivation for writing.
Students may choose to move on from personal narrative. Trying to remove the straitjacket-perception of essay writing, students may write in any genre, on any subject. This school year, essays have included an essay on the origins of inspiration; an essay about bones, inspired by a skeleton discovered in Borneo; an essay on gender misperception from Zora Neale Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God.
Three weeks of Essay-A-Day is successful, in part because of the follow-up: Essay Café.
At the end of each week, we open a classroom café for students to read their essays. Students bring food and drink. Readers are nervous and vulnerable. After each essay, students tell the author what they like. They express their recognition of beautiful language and well written phrases, of undertone, of the second story, or the extended metaphor.
There is laughter; there are tears and group hugs. After a student reads her essay on body image, which includes statements such as, The amount of diets and exercise routines I have been through are countless… no matter what, I didn’t want to look like an elephant,-- the room is quiet. Finally, the silence is broken when a student, a dancer, raises her hand and says, “I needed to hear that today.”
One year, a student wrote about her father’s illness. After she read, another student apologized for judging her because she had become withdrawn and mean. A year later, she understood why.
I often hear one student say to another, “I never knew that about you, and I admire your courage.“
Students learn they can write for an hour a day for three weeks, and that they can write well. They write for each other and not just for the teacher and for a grade. Rigorous editing is natural since they write for an important audience: their peers.
On back-to-school night, a young man introduced himself and said that he loved to read but hated writing. The day before Essay Café, I read his beginning paragraph but had no idea where the essay was going. The next day, he volunteered to read first. His essay began: It started with two teenagers. They were both alcoholics and druggies. The boy lived with the gangsters.
The essay ends when a little boy born to a drug-addicted mother, is discovered by his father. The father gives up drugs and changes his lifestyle to care for his malnourished two-month-old son.
The class burst out, “Who was the little boy?”
“It was me,” the author answered.
The night before Essay Café, with the help of his parents, he had written about his life.
Imagining a student who had hated writing, piecing together the painful story of his life, his parents surrounding, strikes at the deepest emotions of a teacher.
AFter three weeks of developing writing muscle, we keep writing, though it may only be once a week or bi- weekly. This year, in the month after, students tackled an essay on American Immigration, and a synthesis essay on Excellence of Thought using William Golding’s Thinking as a Hobby, Plato’s Allegory of the Cave, and other resources.
One of the best outcomes of writing every day is looking for things to write about. Knowing I want to write well, I am motivated to live well. I force myself to take my kayak into the rougher-than-usual surf so I can write about the pod of dolphins in the bay. When friends call for a last-hour hike, I say “Yes.” Adventure, exploration, and a more open mind are present because I am a writer. To live better is to write better.
In trying to pass off this important writing application to students, I share my own experiences of life enhancement. I challenge students in their writing practice, to first create an experience—it can be as simple as talking to a stranger or sitting at a different lunch table. I challenge students to improve their writing by improving their life.
My self-promise to write an essay-a-day, has not only made life more fun and meaningful, but I have a tangible record of my existence. I’ve worked through burdens and suffering; I’ve recorded funny moments and life surprises. I find an old essay and am reminded of an important principle or event that if not written, would have been lost.
After two weeks of Essay-a-Day, students anonymously summarized their feelings. Almost every student had loved writing without pressure, writing about whatever they wanted. It had become a way to decompress, to sort out feelings, and to better understand the world around them.
Postscript: I received an email from the academic dean. He ran into a past graduate of our school, of my class. The student wanted the dean to pass on a message to me, I’m still writing.
He’d kept his writing muscle.
Works Cited
Atwell, Nancie. Lessons That Change Writers. Heinemann Educational Books, 2002.
Comments