How is the Christmas Tree Holding Up?


 "Did the toy tree work?" one of Jillian's sisters asks.

 "You tell me," she responds. 

Her photo shows a bare-at-the-bottom Christmas tree. Ornaments and lights have mother-migrated upward as the little guy stretched higher and higher.

I predict by the time we arrive on Christmas day, it will be a half-decorated tree--only the upper part will have lights and bulbs.

Children are curious, smart, and not easily fooled.

Jillian's sister, a child psychologist, jumps into the thread: The decoy never completely takes away from the real thing. They always know it's an imitation, like keys or a cell phone--they always want the real one.

How do they know? Because children are authentic. If fooled, it will be momentarily, and long before the parent realizes the child is no longer fooled. 

Perhaps they are so sharp because of the things we try to fool them with. For instance, Santa Claus. The Easter Bunny. The Tooth Fairy? It's rather embarrassing the stories we tell.

Yet how do we remove from our culture such deeply ingrained myths? Perhaps the key is in the name: myths.

Myths are fun stories that try to explain our existence, our traditions, our people. The goodness of Santa Claus is a creation myth for the Savior. The Easter bunny---I'm stumped. The tooth fairy? She's a parent helper or a bribe, when parents used to pull teeth before naturally letting them fall out.

Children have amazing imaginations. There's no reason to keep them from imagining Santa coming down the chimney. There's no reason to stifle visions of the fairy who leaves a coin under their pillow. But children need truth and authenticity, and if it's hidden, they will find it themselves. Whether it's the real bulbs on the real Christmas tree or the phone they grab whenever they get a chance, or spying on Mom on Christmas Eve as she lays out the toys.

Years ago, my daughter’s backyard  ended at the edge of a pond. The  other grandparents worried excessively about the danger. They wanted the children to be told the story they were told as children when they lived near an irrigation canal: the story of the scary monster named Jake who lived in the water.

"No," we said, "tell them the truth instead; teach them the dangers of the canal, and watch them closely."

For how many children might instead, go looking for the monster in the canal?

Truth and authenticity~~not only good for children. 




Comments