Two Winners

Things are a little wompus-mompus this year concerning school. For everyone.

Most California and Nevada students still aren't attending in-person school. 

Fortunately, we are on a split schedule which brings half the student body to school on A days and the other half on B days...which means, students are only attending school two days a week. The other two days they spend online...supposedly.

Some students who are vulnerable because of heart conditions, asthma, or other sensitivities, are home every day of the week. 

My story is about a stay-at-home student and an in-person student, and the competition that brought them together: Poetry out Loud Recitation contest.

Poetry out Loud is a nation wide program with a first place prize of $20,000. Students start with a school competition in which the winner moves on to a regional competition; the winner of regional moves on to state competition. The state first place winner is crowned with the privilege of competing with 52 other students for the national title that includes a free trip to Washington DC.

 One of the first students to sign up for our school was a tenth grader relegated to home because of a health condition. She reached out and asked if she could still compete. "We'll put you on Zoom. It will be great."

I met virtually with student A and found her to be intelligent, lovely, personable. 

Because of the W-M chaos of school, five expected competitors dwindled away like fallen leaves in a soft October wind. The school competition couldn't happen unless there were two competitors. I didn't know what dreams student A had; I didn't know how much she may have looked forward to her virtual poetry recitation. I couldn't let her down. She'd picked, memorized, and practiced her poems already. 

Student B, or David, had shown interest too, and when I'd pinned him down on competing, he responded "Still interested." We came down to the week of the school competition and I hadn't heard back from him. I'd heard he was busy with the school play, Romeo and Juliet. I hunted him down.

"You either have to commit or un-commit." I briefly explained Student A's vulnerability. He admitted he may not have the poems completely memorized, a requirement of Poetry out Loud recitation.

"Just come. We'll have prompters to help you along."

"I'll be there." Yet, he'd committed to a different goal... 

Student A, via Zoom recited her poetry with vigor, emotion, and beauty. Grief by Elizabeth Barrett Browning had never been so heart-lovely. Dawn Chorus by Sasha Dugdale echoed as beautiful as the birds she described. Student A's memorization was perfection.

And then there was Student B. He needed a little more help than previously expected. Yet, his delivery was pointed, professional, humorous; I smiled every few lines at In Praise of my Bed and The Properly Scholarly Attitude. The boy was a master. 

Student A listened via zoom and assumed David was the new Poetry out Loud winner.

What she couldn't have seen was that David consulted his poem-on-paper several times, and each time he was penalized for lack of memorization. 

The winner was an easy choice and barely required of the judges to consult their judging sheets. I decided to gather everyone around the Zoom hearth and explain the results. 

"You are both the best competitors we've ever had." The other judges agreed with me. "But given the circumstances of David not having completely memorized his poems, Student A, you are the winner and will be representing the school in the regional competition."

"I was sure David had won," Student A replied, and her assumptions were fair given she couldn't see what had really happened. There was another thing she nor we could have seen.

David revealed his real goal. "When I learned that Student A couldn't have won without a competitor, I committed to be here so she could go on, even knowing I hadn't memorized my lines completely."

We had in fact, two winners that day. 

Comments