On This Day


My daughter married a wonderful young man from South Carolina--the first state to secede from the Union in 1860.

Let that sink in.

One of the first shocking conversations between my son-in-law and me, revolved around the Civil War. Our short banter ended when he said, “It was about states’rights Pat. States rights.”

I didn’t know how to respond as I’d never heard that position before.  A joking kind of guy, I figured he couldn’t have been serious.

Later when I thought about his statement, I found the answer in a question, What were the states fighting for their states' rights over? Slavery. They fought for their sovereignty and rights to keep slaves. No matter how it was packaged, it was ultimately and always their freedom to control others’freedom.

Growing up in a western state, a territory at the time of the Civil War, I was taught the Civil War was fought to end slavery. The Gettysburg Address, the Emancipation Proclamation followed shortly thereafter by the 13thand 14thamendments, proved it to be so.

But a boy raised and schooled in South Carolina received a different education.

Author Charles B Dew calls himself a son of the south whose ancestors on both sides fought for the Confederacy. Schooled in Virginia, listening to adult conversations, reading limited sources on the Civil War, he also thought the South had seceded for one reason and one reason only: states rights.

Yet, as a historian, he had to investigate further. His investigation is found in, Apostles of Disunion.

It’s a little known story of the southern states desperate attempt to secede together and create their own country.

Almost immediately after Abraham Lincoln was elected as president, the South began to panic. With an anti-slavery president, the South’s peculiar institution was in jeopardy.

Abraham Lincoln hated slavery. He never minced words. But he made it clear in his debates with Stephen Douglas and in his campaign promises that he would not interrupt what was already a long standing practice in the slave states. He would however, do everything in his power to keep slavery from spreading to the territories and states that would enter the union. 

There were a few strong currents flowing against him. First was the abolitionist movement whose goal was to end all slavery. Second, people in the free states who refused support the fugitive slave law. Third were the threat of fanatics like John Brown who believed it was time for bloody resistance against slave holders. An anti-slavery president and the beating drums of a war threat—the slave states jumped into action to defend their states’rights. 

In December of 1860, South Carolina by a unanimous vote seceded from the Union. But they knew they couldn’t stand alone and succeed. They had to recruit the other slave states in joining succession and ultimately creating a confederate government. South Carolina called upon powerful and influential men who were also great orators to become commissioners for the cause of dis-union. The Carolinians were joined by commissioners from Mississippi. The commissioners traveled to the other slave states speaking in conventions, speaking to legislatures, passionately promoting the cause to secede in order to preserve constitutional rights. 

But Charles Dew discovered the truth. He studied, analyzed and concluded from careful studies of the commissioners’s speeches. Their clarion calls had little to do with states’s rights but instead focused on three aspects of racism, all of which were used to create fear.

The first threat was “the looming specter of racial equality.”White supremacy in the South would end and destroy southerners’illusion that the Founding Fathers freedoms were for the white race only.

The second threat was the fear of race wars. Mississippi commissioner Alexander Handy in one of his crusade speeches said that Republicans (anti-slavery party) were infiltrating the south“to excite the slave to cut the throat of his master.”

The third attempted fear was amalgamation of the races. Matrimony among the races would have disastrous consequences and all would be lost, “our property, our liberties.”

The commissioners’efforts were largely successful. By February 1 1861, seven slave states had left the union. In April of 1861 the first shots were fired on Ft. Sumter—the Civil War had begun, but the motivation was not for states’rights. This idea was perpetuated in later years by southerners defending their actions that caused the bloody civil war.

Depending on where you lived and what you believed, the Civil War was fought to deny or confirm the freedoms promised in the Declaration of Independence: 

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness

Comments