New Deal

They are scattered about the school yard, like little black ants foraging their minds for something to bring back, to contribute to the conversation in the classroom. Sometimes, we just need to step outside, breathe deeply and collect thoughts like rays of sunshine.

I want them to think about the "turtle" chapter in Grapes of Wrath, the iconic John Steinbeck story of the Great Depression, the Dust Bowl, and the ache of mankind. Like the men who rode the rails in search of work, we too travel to find understanding to the decade of suffering, want, and the New Deal.

The first man on the railroad we meet is Herbert Hoover. Unlike the president riding in a first class car of his own, we have run to catch the train, must tie ourselves to the catwalk by our belts, must evade the yard bulls so we aren't sentenced to 30 days hard labor on the rails. When the train slows, we inch towards the steam engine for warmth; it leaves our hair full of soot and cinders.

We catch President Hoover just as he embarks the train in New York. It's October 21, 1932 and this very evening he will address supporters in Madison Square Garden. When we ask him what are his greatest concerns, we watch his blood pressure rise and he belts out, "The New Deal! It is a contest between two philosophies of government!" He swears the New Deal will destroy the very foundations of the American system of life. We listen carefully, but we know he will be defeated, we know his promises never become the faith of the people and FDR wins with 57% of the popular vote and an electoral mudslide of 472 to 59. We never know if capitalistic principles, laissez faire, the ingenuity and uprising of the people could have pulled us out of the depression. They never had a chance to prove themselves.

Within the first week of his presidency, Franklin D Roosevelt and his Brain trust have implemented historic changes in America. The Emergency Banking Act of March 1933 shut down banks to stop the run on money. Unemployment programs such as the TVA, CCC, WPA are created to put America back to work, to ease the 20-25% unemployment. Economic safety net programs such as the FERA (modern day FEMA) and Social Security now exist. FDR creates the National Industrialization Recovery Act (NIRA), and the Agricultural Adjustment Agency (AAA) Everything is going just dandy...

SCREEECH.....until the NIRA and the AAA are challenged in court and deemed unconstitutional.

One of the precedent court cases was Schechter Poultry v US. SP argued that the president was given un-delegated power to run industry without any standards. Thus he had the power to regulate industry with unprecedented and unrestrained power. A president just can't have the power to do what he wants without controls.

We catch up with FDR to ask what he's thinking. He reveals to us, his students from the future, his concerns, with the real threat of more constitutional challenges. "I have an idea. I already control two branches of the government--the executive and the legislature; how about a third? The Judiciary. But how could I get away with that?"

We later learn that the great FDR did indeed come up with a plan, one of the slimiest political moves in US history, that would almost tarnish his reputation except for the great service he rendered during WWII. He constructed the Judicial Procedures Reform Bill of 1937....sounds dangerous.

FDR proposed that each Supreme Court member over the age of 70, who didn't plan on early retirement, could be replaced by another judge, up to six judges....uh huh.

But democracy worked! The people spoke out against his court packing plan, as it would come to be known, and even the democratic congress couldn't pass such a stinker. The media was fair, brutal, saw it and called it for what it was. President Roosevelt ceded to the power of the people.


My favorite cartoon of the 1937 debacle.


Did the New Deal grant all its promises? No. Though it did relieve suffering, it didn't take America out of the depression. Tragically, the war revived the nation, and like WWII, the New Deal left its legacy. It too brought extreme change to America: big government, federal deficit, and an independence on the government as the solver of our problems.

Comments