Part 2 of 3:
Another Voice of Dissension: Human Brotherhood Must Be Willed
In 1961, a radical college drop-out began his reformation of the slow-dying League for Industrial Democracy, by renaming it Students for a Democratic Society. In the last month of 1961, Tom Hayden drafted the manifesto of the new liberal organization. At the Port Huron Detroit convention that followed, the reworking of the manifesto, the “fighting for language” (Gitlin, 111), the exhilaration of a fresh political start, was the beginning of an organization that would eventually find a second mission in protesting the Vietnam war.
The vision for the Students for a Democratic Society is found in that beginning manifesto, The Port Huron Statement codified in 1962. It is a message of honest assessment of students’ personal lives, the dangers of a nuclear world, and the realities of human degradation made obvious by Southern racism. Finding hypocrisy in the Declaration of Independence, one of the SDS’ goals was to,
seek the establishment of a democracy of individual participation, governed by two central aims: that the individual share in those social decisions determining the quality and direction of his life; that society be organized to encourage independence in men and provide the media for their common participation.
Civil Rights became the focus of their democratic rights--until the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution, which gave President Johnson a frightening and ambiguous power. After the Viet Cong attacked American barracks at Pleiku, steady bombing began. Gitlin writes, “there was barely a squeak of liberal dissent” (179). The door was open for Students for Democratic Society (SDS) to claim its purpose. By December 1964, SDS “decided to organize a national demonstration against the war” (Gitlin 179).” Their intentions were clear, but they also wanted “a jump on the competition” (180). Anti-Vietnam would become a way of life, a way to notoriety, a way to establish the purpose and power of SDS.
After much deliberation, the SDS agreed to a simple protest statement: SDS advocates that the US get out of Vietnam for the following reasons: (a) the war hurts the Vietnamese people; (b) the war hurts American people; (c) SDS is concerned about the Vietnamese and American people” (181).
The first SDS sponsored march became what was then, the largest peace march in American history. On April 17, 1965 a crowd of approximately 20-25,000 people (mostly students), marched to the White House after hearing speakers that included Senator Ernest Grueling and listening to eminent singers such as Joan, Baez, and Phil Ochs.
The march of April 17, 1965 buoyed the ambitions and passions of the SDS. The momentum continued.
Brewing at the same time was a group of anti-war students and instructors at the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, who wanted a campus strike in combination with instruction on the throes of the burgeoning Vietnam War. The roots in Michigan were firmly in place from the creation of the Port Huron Statement and its initial fight in the Civil Rights Movement. An all-night “teach-in” emerged, an idea borrowed from Civil Rights affiliate SNCC whose protests began with sit-ins, non-violent protests by blacks who seated themselves at whites-only lunch counters. The ideal of teach-ins provided an anti-war learning experience that fit the criteria of peaceful learning and protesting at the same time. It was a viable form of protest within the conformity of the college campus.
The first teach-in of March 24-25 1965, lasted all night and “the atmosphere was considered electric, and copies sprang up on campuses everywhere—even in Europe and Japan” (Gitlin 188).
A teach-in revolution had begun. According to the research of Bronwen McGrath, Columbia University followed with their own teach-in just a day later, and within the next week, 35 universities followed. By the end of the academic school year, over 120 college campuses had hosted teach-in events. However, the setting also provided an opportunity for backlash against protestors. A bomb threat, a clash of words and anger accompanied the purpose driven events, and eventually pro-Vietnam groups held their own teach-ins.
From the early SDS protests, anti-Vietnam dissent gained momentum. Its cumulative effects, not only disturbed and excited Americans, but the Vietnamese who understood the importance of turning the tide of American support.
That tide decisively turned when Lyndon B. Johnson on March 31, 1968, spoke in regards to peace in Vietnam, referring to it as “No other question so preoccupies our people.” Johnson ordered the end (with exceptions) of attacks on North Vietnam. Foremost, he recognized that “The main burden of preserving their freedom must be carried out by…the South Vietnamese themselves.”
President Johnson decreed the need for a stronger nation. He broke the news that he would not be a part of that effort; he was not running for reelection. His foreign policies had fueled an un-winnable war. In one sense he had failed as President. If George Ball’s warnings had finally been heeded, if protesting students had finally been listened to, it was too late for President Johnson.
Comments