Federalist Paper #9 Emergence From Our Errors

In this ongoing argument in support of or dissolution of the constitution, Federalist paper #9 points out an inherent, eternal principle that continues to mar civil discourse and progression. It is that everyone wears a lens from which he adapts viewpoints, experiences, and examples to fit, argue and support his viewpoint.

Hamilton accuses the advocates of despotism (clearly from his lens could such a strong accusation emerge), or those who are against a federal government or a united confederacy of states, as misreading the words of Montesquieu, the great 18th French philosopher who first wrote about the separation of powers.

Hamilton proposes that a strong union will easily deflect "against domestic faction and insurrection. The example that comes to mind is in within a large family. With one rebellious sister among eight other siblings, if the greater number is united, they should have the power either within their persuasion or within their physical strength to subdue by love, persuasion or force the trouble and faction caused by the rebellious sister.

When we exult in the previous republics of long ago, when we admire their moments of felicity, it but dazzles us with fleeting brilliancy--as history doesn't hide that those bright lit moments were soon extinguished by the force of a strong wind.

But....Hamilton is hopeful. We have learned from those failures of ancient governments! he declares, "The efficacy of various principles is now well understood, which were either not known or imperfectly known to the ancients. The regular distribution of power into distinct departments; the introduction of legislative balancers and checks; the institution of courts composed of judges holding their offices during food behavior; the representation of the people in the legislature by deputies of their own election; these are wholly new discoveries, or have made their principle progress towards  perfection in modern times." Hamilton is so imbued with the purity of hope that he predicts one day  America will be the foundation upon which other edifices may build "which will be equally permanent monuments of their errors."

In this statement we find the production of a confederacy, a government that serves its people becomes only so by and through the errors of judgment soon corrected--the corresponding platform upon which human development also exists.

The analogy which emerges from Hamilton's essay that espouses strong states under a federal power is easily missed. I had to have Tony search for it too. The analogy compares the planets that revolve around the sun and coexist beautifully in the same solar system. The separate states revolve in their own sphere, by their own power, connected and held together by a greater power, a national government.

When I view the eventual constitution ratification from the analogy of our solar system, I understand not only the strength of the proposed union, but the absolute necessity.

When I hear California's petitions to succeed from the union, I shudder.  I want the proponents to return to the arguments of 1787, to know the fight was already fought.

I understand Lincoln's inevitable actions of going to war not only to defeat slavery, but to keep the union together. United we stand divided we fall--whether it's a young country, an old country, a family, a corporation, students, even the ideals within our own mind when they fracture with our actions.


Comments