Factions

The greatest threat to any organization, whether it be government, church, or classroom, is the creation of factions. Under its instability, injustice and confusion, it will make popular governments perish; it will destroy the organization from within.

Adversaries to the proposed constitution used factions as its most "specious declamation."

Madison, in Federalist Paper # 10 suggests there are two ways of removing factions. One way would be to destroy the liberty which is essential to its existence." But destroying liberty is worse than the disease.

The second unrealistic option would be to give every citizen the same opinions, passions and interests. But men will always be different and this too is critical to the body politick: men and women of difference. Thus factions naturally emerge by differences in property ownership, in collectors and debtors, in the different stations in which people exist.

Given that differences will create factions, how can a government mitigate the effects of these inevitable factions? The answer, James Madison found was in the republic set forth in the constitution. A republic is not a democracy, but an elected and small group of people who would refine and enlarge public views by passing them through this body chosen for their wisdom, patriotism, and love of justice--which brings to mind the importance of trust in our elected officials in 2018--but of course trust must be established from experience, example and trustworthy actions. Over the last decades, we seem to be losing our trust--and for good reason.

A large republic would also increase the odds of finding the best men (and women); the United States was the perfect set up for these new ideas and principles so hotly contested; as predicted, factions cannot be controlled nor should they be, but the negative effects have been mitigated by the large republic the United States came to be.

Comments