If the anti federalists had their way, the United States's federal power would have stayed in the states' hands. I imagine it would have been like the European Union. That wouldn't have been so bad, is my initial thought. I think how well those cute little European states, each with its quaint hamlets of cobbled streets and gabled structures co-exist so well. How each of their cultures have remained so distinct, and which gives to me, a traveler such an aesthetic experience within a short drive.
Scrrrreeeech....
How quickly our comfort mitigates, even negates the past. Within thirty seconds of that thought, my eyes are rolling. I recall the Hundred Years war in the 14th and 15th century between France and England, and then onto the continual wars between the Scots, the Irish, the Brits; the great wars between Germany and her neighbors--some countries no bigger really than California. What if from 1787 onward, those European states had been united into one great whole. What if Africa with its continual bloodshed among neighbors too had been one great group of united states?
This was Hamilton's plea in the Federalist Paper # 6, "I shall now proceed to delineate dangers of a different ... kind--those which will in all probability flow from dissensions between the states themselves and from domestic factions and convulsions." The conflicts, Hamilton predicted would emerge form "the love of power,...the desire of pre-eminence and dominion, jealousy of power, desire of equality and safety...and competition of commerce."
The Greeks, the Romans, the Carthaginians all had this problem and contested with their neighbors continually and eventually to their downfall. Small states were breeding grounds for the conflicts that lead to conquest.
If instead the United States could become a united commerce working together, these landmines could be avoided, "...what reason can we have to confide in those reveries which would seduce us into an expectation of peace and cordiality between the members of the present confederacy, in a state of separation?"
Publius foresees the need to unite in order to keep peace. "Neighboring nations are naturally enemies of each other, unless their common weakness forces them to league in a confederate republic, and their constitution prevents the differences that neighborhood occasions, extinguishing that secret jealousy which disposes all states to aggrandize themselves at the expense of their neighbors. This passage, at the same time, points out the Evil and suggests the remedy."
One nation, under God, indivisible... the Federalists had a point.
Scrrrreeeech....
How quickly our comfort mitigates, even negates the past. Within thirty seconds of that thought, my eyes are rolling. I recall the Hundred Years war in the 14th and 15th century between France and England, and then onto the continual wars between the Scots, the Irish, the Brits; the great wars between Germany and her neighbors--some countries no bigger really than California. What if from 1787 onward, those European states had been united into one great whole. What if Africa with its continual bloodshed among neighbors too had been one great group of united states?
This was Hamilton's plea in the Federalist Paper # 6, "I shall now proceed to delineate dangers of a different ... kind--those which will in all probability flow from dissensions between the states themselves and from domestic factions and convulsions." The conflicts, Hamilton predicted would emerge form "the love of power,...the desire of pre-eminence and dominion, jealousy of power, desire of equality and safety...and competition of commerce."
The Greeks, the Romans, the Carthaginians all had this problem and contested with their neighbors continually and eventually to their downfall. Small states were breeding grounds for the conflicts that lead to conquest.
If instead the United States could become a united commerce working together, these landmines could be avoided, "...what reason can we have to confide in those reveries which would seduce us into an expectation of peace and cordiality between the members of the present confederacy, in a state of separation?"
Publius foresees the need to unite in order to keep peace. "Neighboring nations are naturally enemies of each other, unless their common weakness forces them to league in a confederate republic, and their constitution prevents the differences that neighborhood occasions, extinguishing that secret jealousy which disposes all states to aggrandize themselves at the expense of their neighbors. This passage, at the same time, points out the Evil and suggests the remedy."
One nation, under God, indivisible... the Federalists had a point.
Comments