Fallible

I have the loveliest student. In every way. I've watched her grow from a quiet ninth grader to a confident senior. She is composed, caring, and clear minded; I always suspected she came from a strong family situation. Yet, as she became more confident in her writing, she wrote about family discord.

A few days ago, she told me she needed to talk. Her countenance was heavy and I wondered if something was terribly wrong.

"Can you talk to me in class or do we need to leave?"

"We need to go outside."

I shut the classroom door and anticipated the worst.

She was on the verge of tears.

"I don't know whether I should write about my parents weaknesses."

Deep breath. I reminded her that writing can be therapy and it might be helpful for her to do so. A caveat followed closely on the heals of this advice.

"Be smart and careful with what you write. I've seen families torn apart when a person publishes writing that disparages a family member."

"Ok," she trembled.

Over the next week, I thought about my student everyday, and I wondered if I should share with her that my parents weren't perfect either.

Years ago, I had another friend, a grown woman, who carried the burden of an imperfect father. She acknowledged he'd done something bad, but she kept it a secret. One day, she called a mutual friend and asked her to come to her house.

The woman broke into tears as if she'd committed the crime herself. She disclosed that her father had murdered another man in an unfortunate accident. His daughter had had nothing to do with it, but she acted as if she did.

Heartbreaking--that love condemns a child to carry a parent's cross. In part because the child thinks she is the only one with human parents capable of mistakes. So, today, as we were discussing the 14th and 15th amendments, I let it out--a costly mistake another parent had made.  My parent. My wonderful, adorable, beloved father. It was okay, especially if Dad knew it might help a teenager know she wasn't the only one with fallible parents.